A Life Worth Eating

• Other Posts

港区南青山5-3-2南青山, Tokyo, Japan, Official Website

My last meal at Pierre Gagnaire, Paris was a roller coaster. Lots of ups and downs and by the end of service I was left holding on to my chair in confusion. Any great restaurant has to take risks in the kitchen to achieve something great. But my original experiences were like a lottery, and after three meals at Gagnaire Paris, I kept losing.

Pierre Gagnaire Tokyo, in some ways, was the complete opposite. There were few risks. Everything was consistent. This is good in the sense that no single course was particularly disappointing; bad, however, that nothing was exceptional. Exceptional cuisine balance risk-taking and spontaneity with consistency, and it’s no easy task. My meal here was an extremely toned-down version of my meal in Paris.

6, Rue Balzac, Paris, France, Official Website

It seems to be a common theme with Parisian Michelin 3-star restaurants: due to pricing and the general difficulty in obtaining reservations, most are geared towards consistency at the expense of risk-taking. This means that most dishes will be excellent but few will be mind-shatteringly delicious. Lifetime memorable dishes take experimentation, precariousness and uncertainty, three elements embodied by a capricious and whimsical chef. Pierre Gagnaire is one of these colorful chefs.

Sure, the restaurant has a menu. But ordering from the menu here is a bit like asking Monet to draw a stick figure: it’s restrictive and doesn’t take full advantage of the chef’s creativity. The best way to experience Chef Gaganaire’s cuisine is to ask the kitchen to cook for the table without restriction. At least that’s what I’d heard from regulars … but maybe their last visit was quite some time ago as this is becoming less and less possible since Chef Gagnaire spends less time behind the stove. Apparently this can make the difference between an extraordinary experience and a disappointing one.